
As the MLB All-Star Game is drawing close, Jon Heyman of SI.com ranks the best and worst free agent signings from baseball’s offseason.
Best:
1. Raul Ibanez, Phillies OF. Before going on the disabled list, he was outperforming by so much that he spawned an Internet debate about whether he might be doing the juice. He has 22 home runs, 59 RBIs and a .656 slugging percentage, a bargain for $31.5 million and three years, or any price really. Here’s my explanation: He’s playing in a better ballpark for hitting (no letters please about his current home-road splits — not playing in Safeco still is a plus), he’s with a better team, he works hard and he’s good. As for the Internet stories, I think they’re unfair without a spec of hard evidence. And no, doing well is not evidence enough.
2. Trevor Hoffman, Brewers closer. He took the chance leaving Southern California (he had an offer to go with the Dodgers) to go for beer and brats, and he hasn’t missed a beat. For a bargain $6 million, his 17 saves are only three off the NL lead, and he missed the first three weeks of the season.
Worst:
1. Bradley, Cubs OF. Who else? He doesn’t always count outs. Of course, if he did, he’d know he’s made plenty of them, way more than his share. An absolute train wreck, he showed his ability to get hurt in spring training, and since then, he’s showed all the other myriad issues. No one should give this man a three-year deal. One good thing, if he doesn’t reach 75 games, the third year is wiped off the books and the $30-million, three-year contract is only a $20-million, two-year deal (still too much for him, though).
2. Oliver Perez, Mets starter. If Mets fans look at that 9.97 ERA, their reaction would be: he’s pitched that well? He’s also being hit at a .315 clip. Omar Minaya liked the fact that he’s young, lefthanded and talented. He’s also a bit of a head case with a knee problem.
To see the rest of Heyman’s best and worst rankings, click here.
It’s kind of ironic that with baseball changing back to being a young player’s game again that the two best offseason signings on Heyman’s list are veterans. Although he’s hurt now and started to cool off before his injury, Ibanez has been amazing for the Phillies and Hoffman has been outstanding for Milwaukee. Another player on Heyman’s list who has been impressive is Dodgers’ shortstop Orlando Hudson, whose numbers should only get better once Manny comes back.
I’m not going to throw salt in the wounds of Cubs fans when it comes to Bradley. I’ll just add that he has been incredibly horrible. And he was supposed to be the answer for Mark DeRosa, who Jim Hendry inexplicably gave away for a tin of chew. And he threw a ball into the stands when there were only two outs in the inning. But that’s all I’m saying on Milton Bradley.