NFL Fanhouse ranked the six best and worst organizations in football.
Top 3:
1. New England: OK folks, start with the rants. Yes, they cheated, but so do other people. Don’t argue with three Super Bowl titles since 2001 and an unbeaten regular season in 2007. Bill Belichick has built by taking players who fit his system over one-dimensional stars. Yes, they’ve been a little less successful drafting lately, and there’s a brain drain — Scott Pioli to Kansas City, Thomas Dimitroff to Atlanta, Josh McDaniels to Denver, Eric Mangini to New York and Cleveland, and (whoops) Charlie Weis to Notre Dame.
2. Pittsburgh: Continuity means three coaches over 40 years, with a record six Super Bowl wins. Dan Rooney, his son Art and the rest of the front office has hired superbly and drafted well. They know luck plays a part — if the Giants hadn’t been able to trade for Eli Manning, they would have drafted Ben Roethlisberger and maybe the Steelers wouldn’t have won two titles in four years. But they get premier players with low picks and develop talent — when it doesn’t gel at first, it still seems to work in the long-run, like with James Harrison, cut and re-signed a bunch of times until he developed into the league’s most dangerous pass rusher.
3. Baltimore: One title this decade and little change at the top, other than the dismissal of Brian Billick after the 2007 season. Who replaced him? John Harbaugh, who fans didn’t know and wasn’t on anyone’s “hot list.” Record so far: 16-6. The continuity comes from Ozzie Newsome, who has been running the personnel operation since 1996 after going straight from a Hall of Fame career on the field to the front office. Twenty-five teams passed on Ray Lewis before Newsome took him and 23 passed on Ed Reed. Joe Flacco looks like the next great QB (if Matt Ryan isn’t already it).
Bottom 3:
30. Oakland: For nearly 40 years after becoming coach in 1963, Al Davis was an innovative thinker. Now he’s an embittered owner, repeating out-of-date slogans, wasting money on players nobody else wants and letting his staff intimidate critics. If he let his CEO, Amy Trask, hire a football guy, it could be consistently better. The Richard Seymour deal was Snyderesque, mortgaging a first-round pick for a declining star. .
31. Cleveland: Why did Randy Lerner jump so quickly to hire Mangini, who treats his players like high school kids? The Browns are 54-110 since returning to the NFL in 1999. Enough said.
32. Detroit: Matt Millen is a very good broadcaster.
I feel bad for the Ford family in regards to the Lions, because they’re a very loyal group that is willing to stick by their hires even when things get rough. That said, they stuck by Millen too long and he wound up dragging the franchise into the depths of hell.
What’s amazing about Oakland is that Al Davis does have an eye for talent. He just operates off emotion and makes decisions on a whim. The Raiders would be much better off if he allowed some else to run the day-to-day operations, but that will never happen.
