10 MLB players to root for in the steroid era
When I was growing up, my friends and I used to walk down to an open field next to a church and play baseball with four rubber bases, one aluminum bat and a tennis ball.
On the way to the field, we used to have mock drafts where we pretended we were general managers picking players for our lineup. When we got to the field, we had to do our best to simulate what each player’s batting stance looked like and then hit like that player.
My favorite player growing up was Giants’ first baseman Will Clark, so after I drafted him I always had to bat lefty (which was a bit problematic since I was right handed and never mastered the art of switch hitting) and stick my right leg straight out in front of me in order to impersonate his stance. And just like “The Thrill,” I had to wear thick eye black and stick a wad of chewing tobacco (well, he had chewing tobacco, I had Big League Chew) in one of my cheeks.
Those are the memories that always make me laugh at myself as a kid. It’s also memories like those that also make me wonder what I would have done if I were a young baseball fan growing up in what should be known as “the steroid era.”
If I drafted Mark McGwire, I guess I would have had to put pillow cushions in each of my sleeves to replicate his big, steroid-enhanced arms. If I drafted Roger Clemens, I guess I would have had to mimic taking HGH before I took the mound and then subsequently pretend to give my girlfriend an injection just as the Rocket did to his wife. (And then lie about everything if I was questioned later about the allegations.)
And I guess if I had drafted Alex Rodriguez, I would have had to not only mimic the steroid use, but also tip one of my friends off about what pitch was coming so that he could pad his stats.
I feel bad for young baseball fans these days. Chances are that their favorite player is/was on the juice and therefore their sports heroes are cheating in order to gain a competitive edge. As it turns out, Will Clark was kind of a dick. But as far as we all know, he played the game the right way and never tried to gain an edge over his fellow players. And unlike A-Fraud, Clark would have rather cut off both his arms than tip an opponent to what pitch was coming.
In effort to help out the young fans across this fine nation, I’ve compiled a list of 10 MLB players (in no particular order) that people can root for as we drudge our way through the steroid era. As far as we know, none of these players have ever taken performance-enhancers, nor have they disrespected the game by playing solely for stats, money or anything else. These aren’t only good guys, but they’re also tremendous ball players that probably don’t get enough credit for staying clean in an unclean baseball fraternity.
(Side Note: I apologize for not mentioning any pitchers, but I was aiming for everyday players when I first decided to compile this list, so that’s what I went with.)
1. Albert Pujols, 1B, St. Louis Cardinals
If you’re looking for the best player in baseball, he’s currently parked at first base in St. Louis. Before the steroid reports surfaced, many believed that A-Fraud was the best player in the game, but there’s little debate now that it’s Pujols who holds that honor. Granted, some question if Pujols has ever used himself, but I’m willing to believe that he’s clean and all the amazing feats he has accomplished on the field to this point have all been steroid-free. Ever since he broke into the league in 2001, he’s been nothing shy of a marvel at the plate and is without a doubt the best pure hitter in baseball.
2. Derek Jeter, SS, New York Yankees
SI.com did a poll last year where over 495 major leaguers voted on the most overrated player in baseball and Jeter took home the (non) honor of ranking first. There’s no doubt his range at short isn’t what it used to be, but Jeter never takes a play off, rarely makes mistakes to cost his team victories and he’s still consistent (albeit unspectacular) at the plate. He also remains great in the clutch, which certainly isn’t easy to do considering he plays in the hardest media market in sports. He might get more attention and praise than his overall numbers suggest he deserves, but I’d rather watch 10 media features on Jeter than just one on A-Fraud.
3. Dustin Pedroia, 2B, Boston Red Sox
I get tired of the “Little Engine that Could” references when it comes to Pedroia. He was a stud at Arizona State and was drafted in second round of the 2004 MLB Draft, yet because he’s 5’9” and 180 pounds, people like to make him out to be the Rudy of baseball. He has always been a talented player, but his drive and devotion to the game is what made him an MVP. Simply put, Pedroia plays the game the way it’s supposed to be played. He thinks up at the plate, always knows the situation in the field and like Jeter, he never takes plays off. Some players have talent, but it goes to waste because of their lack of effort. Pedroia is both talented and a hard worker, and chances are he’s going to be great for a long time because he knows how to get the most out of his abilities.
4. Nick Markakis, RF, Baltimore Orioles
While his popularity is growing each year, Markakis is still a relatively unknown star in this league. He’s a rare five-tool player and because he plays in Baltimore, nobody knows it. He’s not a guy that’s going to hit 50 home runs a year or put up Pujols-like batting average numbers, but he will hit over .300, blast 20-plus dingers, score 100 runs and play a near flawless right field. He’s also incredibly durable, missing just one game in 2007 (that’s one game out of 162, mind you) and just six in 2008. Like all of the guys on this list, Markakis just loves playing the game.
5. Grady Sizemore, CF, Cleveland Indians
What’s not to like about Grady Sizemore? He can hit for power, steal bases and is quite possibly the best centerfielder in baseball. He also didn’t miss a single game in 2006 and 2007, and just five games in 2008, which is not only a testament to his durability, but also to his desire. He’ll probably never be a consistent .300 hitter because he isn’t selective enough at the plate, but he brings so much more to the ballpark on a nightly basis that it’s hard to dwell on his unspectacular average numbers. (Although he is a career .278 hitter, so it’s not like he’s hitting below the Mendoza line or anything.)
6. Aaron Rowand, CF, San Francisco Giants
The Giants grossly overpaid for Rowand as a free agent last year, but that shouldn’t take away from the recognition he deserves as one of the hardest working players in baseball. Rowand never complains, is the ultimate team leader and if I had kids that were interested in baseball, I’d make sure that they were studying how Rowand approaches the game. I’ve never seen a player sacrifice his body more than Rowand and if you’re a true baseball fan, you’ve got to appreciate how he attacks every play as if it were his last.
7. Orlando Hudson, 2B, Los Angeles Dodgers
Orlando Hudson? Seriously? I know, Hudson isn’t the most spectacular player to ever don a pair of baseball cleats, nor will he ever be. But if you watch this guy on a semi-regular basis, you’d see how easy it is to root for him. He doesn’t have Pujols’ talent, but Hudson will stop at nothing to give his team a chance to win, which includes sacrificing his body, his at bats or going all out on routine plays. He also does everything with a smile on his face and it’s rare to see him not sharing a laugh with an opponent or teammate at second base. I hope him hitting in front of Manny Ramirez this year gives his numbers a boost and therefore garners him the attention he deserves.
8. Ian Kinsler, 2B, Texas Rangers
Kinsler is another one of those throwback players like Jeter and Pedroia in that he busts his ass on every play and his intensity exceeds his talent (although that’s not to say that he doesn’t have any, because clearly he does). Kinsler doesn’t excel at one facet of the game, but he does everything well. He can hit for average, a fair amount of power and will steal bases at a decent clip, too. Granted, he does benefit from hitting in a stacked Rangers’ lineup, but that shouldn’t take away from how talented he is and I’m willing to bet if he were in a weaker offense, he’d still put up solid numbers.
9. Hanley Ramirez, SS, Florida Marlins
Ramirez has taken some flack recently for not going all out on every play, but I’ll admit, I’m so intrigued by how good he is at such a young age that I can get past the fact that he’s not Charlie Hustle like the rest of the guys on this list. Ramirez has the talent to be one of the best players in the game and that alone makes him easy to pull for. Hopefully some of his coaches in Florida will get him to realize his full potential and he’ll be a star in this league for years to come.
10. Curtis Granderson, CF, Detroit Tigers
Granderson needs to be more consistent at the plate before he’ll be considered among the best players in baseball, but he does have five-tool talent and what makes him incredibly likable is how much he gives off the field. He established his Grand Kids Foundation in 2008 in order to help underprivileged children in Detroit and other areas get a good education and keep them out of gangs. He also set up a celebrity basketball game last year in which all proceeds went to school systems and inner city children in the Flint and Detroit, Michigan areas. I know a lot of athletes give to charities, but it’s nice to see that a player like Granderson not only donates his time and money, but also continues to be a tremendous role model at all times.
Feel free to shot out a couple players that you feel are easy to root for. I know there are many, many more, which gives fans a little hope for baseball’s future.
Follow the Scores Report editors on Twitter @clevelandteams and @bullzeyedotcom.
Posted in: MLB
Tags: A-Fraud, A-Rod, Aaron Rowand, Albert Pujols, Alex Rodriguez, Alex Rodriguez steroids, Anthony Stalter, Curtis Granderson, Derek Jeter, Dustin Pedroia, Grady Sizmore, Hanley Ramirez, Ian Kinsler, MLB Best Players, MLB Players to root for, Nick Markakis, Orlando Hudson, Sports players to root for, Top 10 MLB Lists, Top 10 sports lists
Awesome, I love pieces like this. Other players I love to root for and am always impressed with:
– Longoria
– Utley
– Peavey
– Ethier
– Pierre
– Garrett Anderson
– Morneau
– Mauer
– Lowell
Chris – love all those guys you listed and heavily considered Longoria and Utley.
first off, you have players, as does chris (longoria especially) who didn’t play in the steroid era.
any list discussing clean players that were robbed by dirty players during the steroid era that does not have Frank Thomas on it instantly fails.
Sorry lyingit, but we’re still in the steroid era, my friend.
I’m not sure that was the point of his list, to identify those who were “robbed.” I think Anthony’s trying to say that, as baseball is trying to distance himself from the steroid era as much as possible, these are talented “old school” ball players who are easy to root for now.
Thomas and Griffey are both guys who played during the steroid era who will get their due in the hall. Perhaps they did get robbed of a couple records, but at least they’ll be able to live a post-career life and look back with fewer regrets than McGwire and Bonds.
What I always found interesting was how often Griffey and Thomas got hurt. They never used steroids to get back quicker and injuries plagued them as they got older. It’s amazing that they’re still playing.
Anthony, how can you contend we are still in the steroid era?
just because players from the steroid era are still playing, does not mean steroids are still dominant through the sport – I think the way teams are winning, and the fact that it’s again a young man’s game, goes a long way to showing that while there still may be some users, the issue is not nearly as predominant as it was during the actual steroid era.
lyingit,
Maybe it’s just my pessimism towards this topic, but I have to believe that a good chunk of the league was still on performance-enhancers coming into the season.
Now is that number dwindling? Absolutely, and as you pointed out in your last comment, the game is definitely changing. This season has had a different feel to it and teams are starting to build around younger players again as you noted in your comment.
But I still think we’re still in the steroid era, or at least at the tail end of it. Bud Seilg has been asleep at the wheel for a long time and while the league has made strides to cleaning up the game, I still wonder what percentage of the league is still juiced up.
Again though, that could just be my pessimism talking.
Great piece – this is real sports writing. Thank you.
The rest of this is my opinion and my opinion alone. I’m not saying it’s right or the only way to look at it. It’s just the way – I – look at it.
Until somebody looks it in the face, I won’t be able to take baseball seriously. What does looking it in the face mean?
Get rid of Selig. He was the top man and thus responsible for the health of the league. He failed in every way imaginable. While Selig remains, there can be no end to the steroid era. Everything he touches is tainted, and nothing he does can change my mind in this.
Test every player every month for a season. Random testing from there on out.
Then I could believe again.
Thank you, Jeff, I really appreciate your comment.
And I couldn’t agree more with your comment on Selig – I flat out don’t trust him and won’t until he does something radical.
Great list. But how about some pitchers. As a Giants fan Lincecum would be my first pick. He is always smiling in the dugout (even on the days when he is pitching).
Thanks, Drew – I apperciate your comment as well.
I’m a Giants fan myself (as if you couldn’t tell by the Will Clark reference in the intro) and besides rooting for “The Franchise” every fifth day, I really enjoy watching Pablo Sandoval play. You can just tell he loves playing the game and as a fan, you have to apperciate that.
As a baseball fan, I have the opportunity to learn about Cardinals my best team , including getting the latest news, schedules and also watching their hottest videos .all this is within a touch in an interesting website I lately discovered:
http://www.cardinalsnet.c
om
I am a Ranger fan & watch/listen to them almost every night. Kinsler is a great talent and still getting better but he does not belong on this list. He often takes naps in the field & I have personally seen him fail to run out infield grounders 2-3 times thgis year when he would have made because of a bobble etc. He also swings for the fences despite being the leadoff hitter and the fact that the team was in a month long offensive funk. Much maturity is needed for him to be classed as a hustling throwbqack guy.
Great list all around, although there are growing whispers about Albert Pujols being juiced. And these days, you’re guilty until proven innocent. As it turns out, most players that were presumed or suspected to be guilty of steroid use did turn out to be guilty.
On another note, I feel that Ichiro is a big omission from this list. Any talk of steroid-free should definitely include Ichiro’s name. Granted he’s not a power hitter, but this guy is 5’9″ and weighs 170 lbs wet, but has played in the most games, most at-bats, most plate appearances, and has produced the most hits among all active players since the beginning of the 2001 season. Currently, only two active players have reached on base more than Ichiro since 2001 and they are Pujols and Abreu. Ichiro’s also 2nd on the list for highest batting average, 3rd on the list for most stolen bases, and 4th on the list for most runs scored among all active MLB players since the beginning of the 2001 season.
He gets on base with uncanny regularity, he’s blazing fast around the bases, has a highlight worthy and accurate canon arm at right field, and been the most durable active player to date.
Stan – thanks for your comments.
I won’t argue with people’s favorites and whether or not they should or shouldn’t be on this list. You love Ichiro and enjoy watching him play – that’s awesome. Any player that plays the game hard and hasn’t used to get an unfair advantage on the field is good in my book.
Like I said earlier, another guy who I would want to squeeze on this list if I re-did it is Pablo Sandoval. That kid just loves playing the game and is a damn fine player…
“I feel that Ichiro is a big omission from this list”
I agree with that. Pujols is too iffy. He seems to have a steroid body and steroid enhanced obscene strength. Of course he could just be a freak of nature, but the odds are way too high for a list like this. Ichiro is a much better bet to be clean.
I bought this the Dr Max Powers Anabolic Stack and I am a lot more muscular then I was a year ago, when he first started using
I have tried several testosterone products out there and have found the Dr Max Powers Test Boost to be the best. It is more than twice as potent as the top brand that I could find and has given me more strengh. I have recovered quicker after work outs and have been able to increase my work out times. It has definitely helped with the ladies too. I have been bulking up pretty well since I have been taking it regularly, and lifting weights.