Donovan McNabb is not a robot!
Donovan McNabb seems thrilled to be free of the Shanahans in Washington.
“Some coaches say ‘Hey, it’s my way or no way,’ ” McNabb said via the St. Paul Pioneer Press. “You become robotic. That’s when you pull away from your style of play and the way of things that got you successful. If things don’t go as well as you’d like them to, you find out what the mistake was, you correct it and you go right back and get it done.”
Mike Shanahan is a control freak. His son Kyle Shanahan, the offensive coordinator in Washington, seems to be even worse. They personify a disturbing trend where coaches try to do too much, and they don’t let their players play. I think if you make football too scripted, you lose the ability to let your players improvise.
I admire teams like the Steelers that put players like Big Ben in a position where he can improvise and make great plays. Of course all of this is a balancing act, but the Shanahans seems to represent the extreme.
I have no idea how McNabb will do in Minnesota. He has some great weapons, but he’s also near the end of the line. That said, he’s a veteran, and it makes sense to let him play the game.
Follow the Scores Report editors on Twitter @clevelandteams and @bullzeyedotcom.
It amazes me that Washington doesn’t try for someone who would fit that system like Kyle Orton. (I know, the Denver thing . . .) Grossman will lull you into thinking he’s good for about 4 games, and then blow it. Orton is better skilled and plays better in a tightly-organized system, whereas guys like McNabb will respond better to having “sandlot” options . . .
Obviously the best combination between player control and letting them run things is Peyton Manning. You can see the thought process play out properly when for example the play breaks down.
Shanahan just simply wants the offense to run on a system, rather than the options of one good player, and not have any surprises (good or bad). What’s funny is, he never did that with Elway, and it means he’s shooting for a system simlilar to the Ravens SB team (which frankly was effective, but utterly boring) and therefore should never shoot for a top-tier QB.
But yeah, dictating snap counts is going a little too far . . .