Clark Judge of CBSSports.com lists the five smartest, boldest and scariest moves by NFL teams this offseason.

Smartest:
Detroit using the first pick of the draft on a QB
There are a lot of things wrong with Detroit, starting with the automobile industry and the Tigers’ bullpen, but the Lions finally got something right: They picked the best quarterback in the draft. Bad teams need to start rebuilding from the ground up, and the Lions started with the most important position. Smart move. They haven’t had a Pro Bowl quarterback since 1972. There was a lot of talk about Jason Smith or Aaron Curry at the top, but let’s face it: You fix the most glaring hole while you can, and if you have a shot at Matthew Stafford you take it. Daunte Culpepper isn’t the solution; Stafford might be. Let’s find out. Give the Lions credit for doing what they should have done.

Boldest:
Chicago trading for Jay Cutler
The question for me is this: Will Cutler handle the winter winds in Chicago better than he handled this spring’s trade rumors? If not, get ready for more whining. I also want to see who serves as Brandon Marshall. I mean, Eddie Royal. How about Brandon Stokley? I smell trouble. Second City has a lot of third receivers.

Scariest:
Kansas City acquiring Matt Cassel
I know what he did with New England. But that was the Patriots, and tell me where you find Randy Moss, Wes Welker, Richard Seymour and Bill Belichick in the 816 area code. Cassel was surrounded by a raft of talent on the field and on the sidelines in New England, and I’m still looking for that support group here. So he produced a couple of 400-yard passing games and won 10 of 15 starts. That was nice. But I want to see him reproduce it here. OK, I know what you’re thinking: What do the Chiefs have to lose — especially when all they surrendered for Cassel and Vrabel was a second-round draft pick? Try this: They’re paying Cassel $14.65 million in guaranteed salary. If he turns out to be the next Scott Mitchell I know some bean counters in red suits who will demand explanations.

To check out the entire article, click here.

How Cassel fares in Kansas City will be incredibly interesting because of the system he played in New England. Pioli wouldn’t have traded for him if he didn’t believe Cassel couldn’t hack it outside of NE, but it remains to be seen if he isn’t just a product of the Pats’ offensive system. At least he has some weapons around him in Larry Johnson (if he isn’t released, that is) and Dwayne Bowe, although the offensive line is still a work in progress and Tony Gonzalez is now in Atlanta.

4th and 26 ranks the top five worst offseason NFL moves of 2008.

1 – The Green Bay Packers trading Brett Favre to the New York Jets. Imagine if your favorite team was 1 game away from the championship and traded away their franchise quarterback the following season? I can’t even begin to fathom how frustrating and depressing it must be to be a Green Bay Packers this season. One game away never looked so far.

The Packers are at 5-7 and for all practical arguments, out of the playoff hunt. At the same time last year the Packers were 10-2. What is the biggest difference between this season and last season? Of course the quarterback would be the biggest difference between both seasons. It certainly isn’t fair to put it all on Aaron Rodgers, but it is hard not to do so when Rodgers is following a legend.
Brett Favre hasn’t had the same offensive year this year as he had last year by the numbers. However, the acquisition of Favre has by no coincidence made the Jets one of the top favorites to win the AFC at this point in the season. Favre may not have the arm that Rodgers has, but he has experience. Favre was the unquestioned leader of the Packers and a team without a leader is due to fail.

The Packers just can’t seem to get any momentum this season. The Packers are missing that spark that #4 gave them every game day. The old man had plenty left to give and unfortunately for Packers fans, he is giving it to someone else. All good things must come to an end in the NFL, but now was not the time for the Green Bay Packers. The Green Bay Packers will go down as not only making one of the worst moves of the year, but maybe one of the worst moves in NFL history.

This was the worst offseason move in 2008? Sucka what? Yes, Favre has lifted the Jets this season, but the reason why the Packers are losing has little to do with Aaron Rodgers. They’re losing because they can’t stop the run, don’t generate a consistent pass rush and didn’t have much of a running game for the first half of the season. Rodgers has thrown for 2,897 yards, 20 touchdowns, 10 interceptions and has a QB rating of 91.2. Favre’s thrown for 2,708 yards, 20 touchdowns, 14 interceptions and has a QB rating of 90.4.

The difference is that Jet Favre had a defense last year in Green Bay. Rodgers doesn’t.